
COMMISSION AGENDA
Tay Yoshitani, Chief Executive Officer
November 13, 2009
Page 2 of 3
Exhibit A
The Exhibit is updated to reflect increases to the ranges for Police and Fire Chiefs, Deputy
Chiefs and Assistant Chiefs. The increases to these ranges maintain an established differential
between the ranges for chiefs and represented employees in the Police and Fire Departments.
PROPOSED CHANGES
There are very few substantive changes from the 2009 resolution. Most changes are made to
clarify sections of the resolution that have generated questions throughout the year. Noteworthy
revisions to the resolution include:
III.A. Salary Ranges: We recommend no increase to salary ranges for 2010. At the
beginning of the Port’s 2010 budget cycle, we recommended a 1.5% salary range increase.
However, due to budget constraints and the current economic environment no increase is
recommended at this time. Maintaining the current range structure through 2010 could present
retention and hiring challenges if hiring activities in the local labor market increase substantially
before the end of 2010 as increases in hiring activities are often accompanied by an upward
pressure on actual pay levels.
Salaries of the Port’s non-represented employees fall within a graded salary range structure.
These ranges do not tie an employee’s pay to a specific step or rate as many other public
employers’ structures and some of the Port’s represented structures do. Rather, the ranges
provide the framework for non-represented employees’ salaries. Most public employers increase
salary ranges based on changes in the Consumer Price Index (CPI) and their employees receive a
Cost of Living (COLA) pay increase equal to the range increase. In addition to the COLA
increase some public employers also provide automatic annual step increases. Non-represented
employees at the Port earn performance-based pay increases and rarely receive automatic
increases.
Each year, the compensation staff reviews and analyzes data from various salary surveys to
determine how our pay ranges compare to average market pay rates. This analysis is the basis
for adjustments to the Port’s ranges. This is different than the CPI change approach most public
employers use. This year, our analysis of the labor market indicates the Port’s salary ranges are
an average of 1.2% below market.
In addition to the customary annual market pricing analysis that market prices all non-
represented jobs as one group, we also market priced exempt and non-exempt jobs separately.
We market priced exempt jobs on an annual basis and converted salary survey data to an hourly
basis (based on a standard 40 hour work week) and market priced non-exempt jobs on an hourly
basis. That analysis revealed that the Port is 1.1% below market for exempt jobs (not eligible for
overtime pay) and 6.2% above market for non-exempt jobs (eligible for overtime pay). A one
year study is not sufficient to determine what, if any, action is needed to close the gap between